A Brief Primer for Adaptive Choice-Based Conjoint

Adaptive Choice-Based Conjoint
By Ken Donaven, Martec Director

Although it may be cliché to start with a statement like “throughout the history of commerce,” in this case such a grandiose, all-encompassing statement may be justified. Essentially since the invention of the wheel, product manufacturers have asked, “what makes my product valuable and sets it apart from the competition?” and “how can I maximize the value, price and profit for my product?” Manufacturers know all too well that the right features, or combination of features, can make the difference between a huge success and an unmitigated failure. However, determining what buyers want and effectively marketing those differentiating features often is extremely challenging.

So, how can manufacturers determine what features are most valued? Simply asking customers what they value is helpful, but it often doesn’t provide enough insight to place a value on those features. Sure, I would love an iPhone with a five-day battery life, but am I will to pay $2,000 for it? Probably not.

In the past, manufacturers and their research suppliers often have utilized choice-based conjoint (CBC) or adaptive conjoint analysis (ACA) methodologies to help answer these questions and to understand the tradeoffs made by consumers among a specified set of product features and attributes. These methodologies work well, but both have limitations.

  • CBC is only useful for a limited number of attributes and price is generally a linear function of the product as a whole.
  • ACA on the other hand is able to handle a larger number of attributes, but the process is often cumbersome and can lead to respondent fatigue and inconsistent results.

While CBC and ACA still have their place in the research toolbox, now a more robust modeling methodology is available. The Sawtooth Software company developed and launched a new trade-off software called Adaptive Choice-Based Conjoint (ACBC). This software has been successfully deployed when clients need a deeper understanding of customers’ decision-making and product configuration processes. ACBC leverages many of the best aspects of both choice-based conjoint and adaptive conjoint, while being more respondent-friendly to use.

So, what is Adaptive Choice-Based Conjoint and how does it work? ACBC projects provide deeper insights into how consumers make decisions and trade-offs with regard to complex products or services and involves a multi-step process to quantify those decisions.

The approach begins with a “build-your-own” exercise, which allows respondents to configure products and services to their specific needs/wants while considering the price premium or discount associated with the pre-defined attributes and levels. This exercise is similar to buying a product online. Want a bigger hard drive, there is an upcharge; don’t want or need a keyboard, the price is lower. We often refer to this as the Mr. Potato Headphase of the research. Add a piece here, remove a piece there…essentially, customers build the product they would most like to purchase.

Once respondents have “designed” the product or service to suit their needs within their budget parameters, the task is taken to the next level. At this next stage, respondents are asked to evaluate several product configurations with similar features to determine “must have” and “never have” features. Essentially, the ACBC software tracks whether respondents are drawn to particular features or repeatedly find any features unacceptable in order to determine the final consideration set.

With the consideration set finalized, product configurations are then presented in a choice-based forum. This forum is essentially a process of elimination for the product features in the consideration set, requiring respondents to choose the most desirable product configuration and ultimately, their preferred product configuration, inclusive of price.

When the ACBC data is analyzed, researchers can provide a deeper understanding of the value of individual product features. Going back to my iPhone example, we may find that a majority of consumers are willing to pay $2,000 for a five-day battery life and are willing to “trade-off” thinness to get that battery life.

So how can ACBC help you? In addition to keeping respondents more engaged and connected to the research process (through a more dynamic Q&A structure) and allowing for a better understanding of the specific value of individual features, ACBC projects are able to include a greater number of attributes and even work well among the small populations and sample sizes common to B2B research. Finally, ACBC provides insight into both solid behavioral theory (consideration first, then choice) and statistical theory (experiment and choice data).

Gone are the days of guessing what customers want or asking your salespeople what they “think” your customers want to buy. Manufacturers can now understand, early in the product development cycle, what customers value and what they are willing to pay for specific features…without investing millions in a potential flop. Personally, I would love a longer battery life on my iPhone. Am I willing to forego other features and/or pay $2,000 for that iPhone? That remains to be seen.

Related reading: Exploring Conjoint Analysis Tools

Subscribe To Our Newsletter
Get The Latest Insights

Leading #MRX Posts

Customer Experience

The Use of AI in Quantitative Research: What to Adopt, What to Avoid

The integration of artificial intelligence into market research processes has been embraced by some as a game-changer, promising to streamline data collection, enhance analysis, and drive informed decision-making. However, as with any technological advancement, the advent of AI brings both opportunities and challenges, prompting researchers to navigate the terrain with caution and curiosity alike.

Read More »
Customer Experience

Show Me, Don’t Tell Me.

One of our recent innovations in our ongoing pursuit to optimize and perfect Emotion Intelligence research is the use of images in a “qual-then-quant” process to gain deeper and more authentic insights into how emotions and sentiment are driving purchase decisions (or not).

Read More »

eBook: Measuring and Optimizing the Customer Experience

It is critical, when analyzing and working to optimize customer experiences, that three primary tenets of sound CX design be woven deeply into the fabric of the analysis, even when using artificial intelligence or other technology to do some of the information gathering and processing.

Read More »
Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top